Share this

If you are planning a new roof at the Shore or anywhere in Central Jersey, and you have been looking into metal roofing NJ options, you may be wondering whether metal is worth it or whether a good asphalt shingle roof is still the smarter choice. Our crew at Jar Roofing Repair installs both, so this guide walks through how each material handles our wind, salt air, snow and summer heat, and when we honestly recommend one over the other.

Javier, our owner, started in roofing more than 20 years ago doing repairs, and that background shapes how we look at this question. We see what fails and why. Most of the residential roofs we work on are asphalt shingles, and we also install standing seam and exposed-fastener metal panels on homes.

Metal Roofing NJ vs. Asphalt Shingles: The Quick Comparison

Factor Asphalt shingles Metal roofing
Upfront cost Usually the lower upfront investment Usually a higher upfront investment
Look Classic, fits most NJ neighborhoods and HOAs Clean modern lines (standing seam) or a more rugged panel look
Snow Snow tends to sit on the roof Snow tends to slide off, so plan for where it will land
Salt air No metal to corrode, but wind and age still wear shingles Performance depends heavily on the metal, coating and fasteners chosen
Repairs Individual shingles are simple to repair Repairs need a crew familiar with the specific panel system

For a deeper look at all the options, including tile and slate, see our guide to choosing the right roofing material.

How Asphalt Shingles Hold Up in New Jersey

Asphalt shingles are on most homes we see in Monmouth and Ocean counties. They are familiar, they come in a wide range of colors, and they are straightforward to repair after a storm. When a few shingles blow off in a nor’easter, we can usually match and replace them without touching the rest of the roof.

We are a GAF Master Elite Certified Contractor. GAF says it gives that designation to less than 2% of roofing contractors, and it means we install GAF shingle systems the way the manufacturer intends. We work mainly with GAF and other well-known brands, because the quality of the whole system (underlayment, ventilation, starter strips, ridge caps) matters as much as the shingle itself.

The weak spots for shingles in our area are wind and age. Lately we have been getting a lot of calls for storm and rain damage, and lifted or missing shingles are a big part of that. If you’ve had a rough storm recently, our checklist on wind damage to your roof is a good place to start.

What Metal Roofing Brings to New Jersey Homes

Standing seam vs. exposed-fastener panels

Standing seam panels lock together at raised seams, and the fasteners are hidden under the panel. Exposed-fastener panels are screwed through the face of the metal, so the screw heads and their washers are visible and exposed to the weather.

Salt air: it depends on the metal and how close you are to the water

Coastal homes in Neptune, Asbury Park, Long Branch and Point Pleasant deal with salt air every day. The Metal Roofing Alliance notes that suppliers usually define a marine environment by distance from salt water, typically anywhere from 1,000 feet to one mile. The MRA lists aluminum, stainless steel, zinc and copper as preferred metals for coastal settings, recommends concealed fasteners to limit exposure, and warns that stainless components should never touch aluminum, Galvalume or galvanized panels directly.

The takeaway for metal roofing NJ projects near the beach: the metal, coating and fasteners have to be matched to your location. Settle this with your contractor and the manufacturer’s coastal guidelines before you sign anything.

Snow shedding: a benefit with a catch

Metal is slick, so snow tends to slide off instead of sitting on the roof. That reduces the load on the roof, but a sheet of sliding snow can land on a walkway, a deck, a car or a lower roof. Metal panel maker Fabral explains in its technical bulletin on snow guards that guards limit the momentum of snow and ice, help protect people walking below, and that sliding snow can bend standing seams. Before a metal roof goes on, we talk with you about where snow will slide off, so it does not come down over doors, walkways or decks.

Energy and cool roof coatings

According to the U.S. Department of Energy, cool roofs can lower air conditioning needs by reflecting more sunlight. DOE also points out that unpainted metal is a good solar reflector but a poor thermal emitter, so metal should be factory-coated with a light or cool-colored paint for cool roof performance. DOE notes that cool roofs can carry a winter heating penalty in colder climates, which is worth weighing in New Jersey, where we get both hot summers and real winters.

When Asphalt Shingles Make More Sense

  • You want the lower upfront investment and a proven, easy-to-repair roof.
  • Your HOA or neighborhood expects a traditional shingle look.
  • Your roof has many valleys, dormers or skylights that make metal panels harder to lay out.

When Metal Roofing Makes More Sense

Here is when we tend to point homeowners toward metal roofing NJ installs:

  • You plan to stay in the home a long time and want to put off the next replacement as long as possible.
  • You like the clean look of standing seam on a modern home, porch, addition or garage.
  • You want snow to shed and your roof layout sends it away from doors, walkways and the driveway.
  • Your roof is a simple shape with long, uninterrupted runs, which suits panels well.

Whatever you choose, installation and maintenance are what decide how long a roof lasts. Our article on the lifespan of your roof covers what shortens and extends it.

What Affects the Cost of Each Roof

We don’t publish prices because every roof is different, and a number online rarely matches the real job. These are the factors that move the price up or down for both shingle and metal roofing NJ projects:

  • Roof size and pitch. Steeper roofs need more safety setup and more labor.
  • Complexity. Valleys, chimneys, skylights and dormers add flashing work and cutting.
  • Tear-off. How many layers are coming off and what the decking looks like underneath.
  • Material choice. Shingle line, metal type, panel profile and coating.
  • Coastal requirements. Corrosion-resistant metals and fasteners for homes near salt water.
  • Extras. Ventilation upgrades, underlayment and flashing details.

If your current roof is only partly damaged, you may not need a full replacement yet. Read roof replacement vs. roof repair to see which situation you are in. And because spring and summer are our busiest seasons, planning ahead helps; here’s our take on the best time to replace a roof in New Jersey.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is metal roofing a good choice for homes near the Jersey Shore?

It can be, as long as the metal, coating and fasteners are chosen for a coastal location. The Metal Roofing Alliance lists aluminum, stainless steel, zinc and copper as preferred coastal metals and recommends concealed fasteners. Ask your contractor which products fit your distance from the water.

Is a metal roof louder in the rain?

Rain can sound different on metal. A lot depends on what sits under the panels, such as solid decking, underlayment and attic insulation, so ask about those details if noise is a concern.

Does snow slide off a metal roof?

Usually, yes. Metal sheds snow more readily than shingles, so it is worth planning the roof layout around doors, walkways, decks and lower roofs where sliding snow could land.

Do you install metal roofs on commercial buildings?

Right now our metal roofing work is residential. For commercial flat roofs we install TPO and EPDM systems.

How much does metal roofing NJ installation cost compared to shingles?

It depends on roof size, pitch, complexity, tear-off and the metal you choose. Metal usually costs more upfront than asphalt shingles. The best way to get a real number is an inspection of your roof.

Do you offer warranties?

Yes. We offer warranties on both labor and materials. We will go over the details for your specific roof and product during your estimate.

Talk to Our Crew About Metal Roofing NJ Options

If you are weighing metal against shingles, we’re happy to come look at your roof and give you an honest opinion, even if the answer is a simple repair. Jar Roofing Repair LLC is a fully insured, GAF Master Elite Certified Contractor serving Neptune, Eatontown, Asbury Park, Long Branch, Red Bank, Freehold, Toms River, Brick, Wall Township, Point Pleasant and nearby towns. Inspections are free in some areas, so ask when you call. Reach us at (732) 682-5451, visit us at 3030 W Bangs Ave, Neptune, NJ 07753 or 2 Industrial Way West, Suite 301, Eatontown, NJ 07724, or request your roof inspection online.

 

metal roofing NJ | metal roof vs shingles | standing seam metal roof New Jersey | asphalt shingle roof NJ | metal roof Jersey Shore | roof replacement Monmouth County

Share this